Miss Miller successfully represented a Formula 1 racing team having been instructed by Make UK, in a claim for automatic unfair dismissal due to an alleged breach in working time regulations.
The employee worked in the “Stores” during the build phase of the formula one race season. He was also required to work abroad in Italy to assist with the build and receiving parts. The hours worked were outside of 48 hours a week during this phase.
The employee stated that he did not receive his breaks under regulation 10, 11 and 12 of the Working Time Regulations. The Respondents stated that he was inevitably dismissed for gross misconduct, his relationship having broken down with his line manager who evidentially, he had disrespected since the commencement of his promotion.
The Claimant tried to allege that he was dismissed for asserting his statutory right as opposed to a breakdown in the relationship. The matter in issue was the reason for his dismissal and whether it amounted to automatic unfair dismissal by asserting his statutory rights.
The Judge found in favour of the Respondents on each contested point raised by the Claimant, and it was found that the reason for dismissal was a breakdown in the relationship and not because he asserted a statutory right.
Miss Miller was able to expose untruths by the Claimant in a forensic cross examination by looking through various messages and emails between the Claimant and his works colleagues, time sheets, visits to the canteen and an analysis of his recorded working hours and inconsistent statements.
It was found that the employee was able to attend his breaks, that the company provided the working arrangements to facilitate his breaks despite longer working hours, and if he chose not to take his breaks, the company were not liable in those circumstances.
Written by Janita Patel